2022 INSURANCE COMPANIES REPORT CARD
None of the 10 largest auto insurers in the country scored higher than the national average score (718) to earn a “B-” or better grade.
Among this group, American Family and Travelers scored the highest with a grade of a “C+,” barely earning them a spot among the top 60 graded insurers nationally. American Family was also the only insurer among the largest 10 to see its grade improve (from a “C” last year).
Allstate earned the lowest grade among the 10 (“D+,” down from “C-” last year). USAA, Liberty Mutual and State Farm also saw a decline in their grade and ranking this year.
2022 INSURANCE COMPANIES REPORT CARD SURVEY COURTESY OF CRASH NETWORK
If you would like to see the complete results of all insurance companies and how yours scored, you can download the complete results here.
| American Family | C+ | 55 | 637 |
| Travelers | C+ | 60 | 603 |
| USAA | C | 70 | 547 |
| Nationwide | C | 71 | 546 |
| Progressive | C | 74 | 539 |
| Farmers Insurance | C | 76 | 496 |
| GEICO | C- | 79 | 455 |
| Liberty Mutual / Safeco | C- | 80 | 440 |
| State Farm | C- | 83 | 423 |
| Allstate | D+ | 87 | 362 |
It will take hours or days for a quality repair to put your vehicle back in its pre-loss condition. This is to ensure that the repairs meet the OEM’s standards on how they want their vehicles to be fixed. If and when the auto sustained another impact, it will crash the way it was designed to.